According to several polls, most Americans do not welcome an instant replay of the 2020 election—Trump versus Biden. An overwhelming majority of Americans want the country to move on for a variety of reasons—age, indictments, too much baggage and more. I agree.
The philosopher John Locke coined the term “tabula rasa” which means a mind as a blank slate with no preconceived ideas—a mind which has not begun to process ideas from outside forces.
So, here’s a concept. Let’s wipe the 2024 presidential candidate slate clean and start over. Let’s select two sane reasonable moderate Republicans and two sane reasonable moderate Democrats and give those currently running their walking papers.
You say it sounds farfetched. You say it’s not going to happen. You’re probably right, But a girl can dream. Here’s my dream scenario. Some well-respected legal scholars claim that Trump is not eligible to run because he violated the 14th Amendment by inciting an insurrection. What if they are right? What if the case goes before the Supreme Court and five Supreme Court Justices agree that this is so? That would mean Trump could never run for public office again.
Then, maybe, just maybe, if Trump were out of the picture, Biden wouldn’t feel compelled to run. Maybe, just maybe, he would step aside and encourage younger, more vibrant, more articulate leaders who are prepared to support future generations to run.
And maybe, just maybe, if Trump were out of the picture, some sane Republicans would step up to the plate and call for a reset to normalcy and promote civil discourse, compromise, and fiscal responsibility.
And were this dream to continue, who would those candidates on my wish list be?
On the Republican ticket, perhaps former Ohio Governor John Kasich as president and our own former Governor of Maryland Larry Hogan as Veep. These are two sane reasonable men who have tons of experience, know how to reach across the aisle, and who have appealed to both Republicans and Democrats. There are many more combos to consider—New Hampshire Governor Chris Sununu and Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski as cases in point.
On the Democratic side, how about Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer as a presidential candidate and California Governor Gavin Newsom as Veep? Both these governors have garnered votes from the other party, and both are young, vibrant and support climate change, Ukraine, sound economic policies and more. There are many other such Democrats waiting in the wings—Minnesota Senator Amy Klobuchar, Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg, Pennsylvania Governor, Josh Shapiro, Secretary of Commerce, Gina Raimondo come to mind. (I would be most excited if a qualified woman were the Presidential candidate as it is past time for a woman to be president of the United States.)
You may ask why not consider some of the Republican candidates who debated last week? Why? Because six of the eight said they would support Trump if he were the nominee. They did not qualify their support and say unless he was convicted of a felony. They just blindly said they would support him. Chris Christie and Asa Hutchinson did not raise their hands. But Christie has a ton of baggage, and Asa Hutchinson has his own age issue.
Wiping the slate clean is sometimes the right answer. When workplaces become toxic, or a Board is unethical, wiping the slate clean makes good sense.
Therapists who use the tabula rasa theory in their practices claim that patients who have anxiety, for example, suffer from that malady because of learned behaviors. Their therapies focus on unlearning those “target situations” and imagining “target situations” differently and therefore reactions become different as well. Basically, they focus on unlearning learned behaviors.
I say we as Americans should unlearn some of our past learned behaviors and react differently to some “target situations.” Let’s stop the vindictiveness, name calling and crude behavior and once again try civility, try listening to the other side, try compromise when appropriate, and try dealing with issues with a sense of compassion, kindness, and humility.
And remember as Buddha once said, “No matter how hard the past is, you can always begin again.”
Maria Grant was principal-in-charge of the federal human capital practice of an international consulting firm. While on the Eastern Shore, she focuses on reading, writing, piano, kayaking, gardening, and nature.
Joan Berwick says
I REALLY like this idea!
A girl can dream.
Brenda Holloway says
Is there any such thing as moderation in politics anymore? The broadcast media and social media work to create controversy since that is what generates a response. I applaud your dream and would love to see lessons in civility be required in school. Here’s hoping some of those dreams come true.
James Nick says
In last week’s televised Republican cage match, Vivek Ramaswamy, the latest trump mini-me and wannabe VP, said “… Some others like you on this stage may have an, ‘It’s morning in America speech.’ It is not morning in America. We live in a dark moment and we have to confront the fact that we’re in an internal sort of cold cultural civil war and we have to recognize that.” He was enthusiastically cheered by the audience.
Also last week, Sarah Palin, one of the dimmest of the dim bulbs to have ever graced the political stage, opined that “Those who are conducting this travesty [the prosecution of trump] and creating this two-tier system of justice, I want to ask them what the heck, do you want us to be in civil war? Because that’s what’s going to happen. We’re not going to keep putting up with this.”
This was hardly the first time the drumbeat of civil war has been sounded by the right. There has been an iterative process of exponentially increasing fear mongering over generations now that has systematically moved the conservative base closer and closer to a raging boil, with the emphasis on “rage”.
Kudos to Ms Grant for desiring a reboot to clean the slate and seek compromise but declarations of “dark moments” like those of Ramaswamy and Palin seem to suggest that if this country hasn’t irreversibly passed the event horizon of the abyss at this point, it is well on its way.
How can there be compromise with a party that, for example, vehemently rejects the science of global warming and twists the facts? Again from Mr Ramaswamy…”The climate change agenda is a hoax … more people are dying of bad climate change policies than they are of actual climate” when in fact in the 10-year period from 2012 to 2022, the U.S. experienced 166 billion-dollar weather disasters that caused $1.28 trillion in damage and resulted in 5,871 deaths [1]. And that doesn’t yet include what may be a death toll exceeding 1,000 in the Maui wildfires.
How do you compromise with a party that fear mongers by emotionally manipulating the base by constantly insisting that abortion on demand and late-term abortions are features of the left’s agenda when, in fact, no credible politician on the left advocates for the former and the latter happen because something has gone seriously wrong with the pregnancy that puts the mother’s life at risk and are incredibly rare.
And it goes on. How do you compromise with a party that thinks more guns will make this country safer but transgenderism, gay rights, and universal healthcare will destroy us? How do you compromise with a party that promotes doubts about the safety and efficacy of vaccinations? How do you compromise with a party that embraces and promotes insane and incendiary conspiracy theories. Etc, etc, etc….
Kumbaya Ms Grant… Kumbaya.
1.https://www.forbes.com/advisor/homeowners-insurance/natural-disaster-statistics/#one
Bob Moores says
A redneck driving his pickup truck thru Chestertown with waving giant flag saying “F__k Biden”. Yes, you got our attention with your crudeness, your bitterness, your grievance. Trump made hatreds that had been suppressed for decades permissible. No wonder he’s the darling of the KKK, Proud Boys, Oath Keepers, and other white supremacists. His mug shot will live forever beside those of Capone and Gotti.
Trump supporters, why do you think he is running for president? Is it to do something for our country or to stay out of jail? Why does he want his many trials to be postponed until after the election? His only hope is that if he can be elected again he’ll be able to pardon himself.
Beautifully written, Maria. I wish you dream could come true. Release us from the nightmare of the possibility of another Trump presidency. And James, the only thing I can say about your analysis is “Amen”.