To the Editor;
No doubt elected officials have the right to state publicly their opinions on elections and candidates if they choose. We who cherish our constitution hold our right of free speech sacred. I worked with Sheriff Hickman prior to my stepping down as state’s attorney and have always held him in high regard. I respect and support his right to speak his opinions. In my humble opinion, however, the Sheriff has misstepped in his publication of an endorsement for the opponent of current State’s Attorney DiGregory.here.
Hickman stresses the importance of transparency. Should this transparency include police/prosecutor relationships? The Sheriff and State’s Attorney are responsible for working interdependently to ensure the public’s safety and confidence in law enforcement. That Hickman would skip basic courtesy and not tell DiGregory, prior to making a public statement that he was switching his support from the current State’s Attorney to that of DiGregory’s opponent, was an error. It was a broadside that DiGregory had no idea was coming. And it runs afoul of basic expectations of trust and mutual respect that are essential in good law enforcement. Someone will likely remind me that things like respect and courtesy, are not mandatory, and I accept that. It is evidenced daily in our national politics. Perhaps Hickman simply chose (without malice) not to have a conversation with DiGregory that could have been productive, although perhaps awkward or difficult.
Second, transparency is not served by inferring that FOP Lodge 110 speaks for all of County law enforcement. There are, in fact, officers who support DiGregory. Why the secrecy around the FOP endorsement? I would find it helpful to know how many officers are members of the FOP Lodge 110. How many attended the meeting in which the endorsement vote was taken? And what was the vote count? No numerical vote tally was provided but we do know the vote was not unanimous. An organizational endorsement is a legitimate expression of the FOP lodge’s decision, but it should not be interpreted or presented as the individual position of every law enforcement officer in Kent County.
DiGregory’s office has an open-door policy to support the free flow of information and frank discussion of concerns among law enforcement. Some police officers have taken advantage of the policy to seek advice on cases or to ask how and why certain things were done in specific cases. Last year DiGregory invited the Sheriff and local police chiefs to the State’s Attorney’s Office specifically to ask whether there were any concerns with their working relationship or issues that needed to be addressed. The Sheriff met with DiGregory and the office’s investigator and indicated that things were going well. No concerns. Since that meeting, no concerns about their professional working relationship have been brought to the State’s Attorney’s attention by Sheriff Hickman, until now.
Susanne Hayman
Chestertown






































15 Responses
The comments by Ms. Hayman were spot on in all regards. The FOP “endorsement” should have properly listed the number of yeas and nays. A simple majority does not properly represent the views of all.
Blindsiding the sitting Stares Attorney was unprofessional at least and should be called out for what it is. A political hit job.
Most importantly, Sheriff Hickman has no business before the Kent County States Attorney’s office. His is with Queen Anne’s.
He needs to stick to business on his side of the river. Should his preferred candidate not win; he has created an unprofessional level of distrust that will difficult for all parties involved.
Dennis Hickman is Kent County’s Sheriff and Gary Hofmann is Queen Anne’s County’s Sheriff. I do agree that it is unusual for an elected official in one jurisdiction to endorse candidates for public office in another jurisdiction.
Thank you for elucidating the other side of Sheriff Hickman’s public endorsement of Mr. Crouch. You would think he would know better.
Well said Ms. Hayman. It seems as if the formally acceptable rules of decorum that maintained professionalism and cordiality have been thrown out
since 2016.
We are living through the consequences even in local elections.
Shame on Hickman for this last minute criticism and for not telling Bryan he was about to do it. Pretty underhand and sneaky.
As Election Day approaches, the political punches are flying. That should come as no surprise in a competitive election.
Former State’s Attorney Susanne Hayman, who last held office 27 years ago, suggests I violated professional courtesy by not informing Bryan DiGregory before endorsing Matt Crouch. I respectfully disagree. I supported Bryan previously, but past support does not create a lifetime obligation. My responsibility is to make an independent judgment about what is best for Kent County.
Perhaps 20 years after I retire as Sheriff, voters will still value my opinion about who should hold that office. But I hope they will also recognize that those currently serving have firsthand knowledge of today’s challenges.
Ms. Hayman also questions Kent County FOP Lodge #110’s endorsement. The Lodge followed the same process used when Bryan received their support. There appeared to be no objections then. Why question the process now because the outcome is different?
Everyone is entitled to an opinion. However, the current elected Sheriffs of Kent and Queen Anne’s Counties, along with Kent County FOP Lodge #110, have endorsed Matt Crouch.
Those actively serving in law enforcement have firsthand knowledge of the challenges facing Kent County and the State’s Attorney’s Office. These professional perspectives deserve serious consideration.
This election is not about hurt feelings or political loyalties. It is about who will better serve the citizens of Kent County.
I have made my decision, and I stand by it.
Dennis W. Hickman Jr.
Totally agree with Dennis Hickman. Dennis has the right to have his own opinion and does not have to inform DiGregory before hand. I would vote Matt Crouch ALL DAY LONG if I could. Apparently, things are not going well with the state’s attorney and doesn’t seem to be doing the best. Time for a change! I hear things everyday! DiGregory is a lot of talk and repeats himself often experience, experience, experience, but yet wanted to hire Matt. No need to say more! Vote Matt Crouch!!!
I think this whole thing has just made DiGregory more appealing to voters.
Just a question for Bryan supporters: Have any of you actually come to any court proceedings? Have any of you researched the criminals that he has willingly let back out into our community? Most of you seem to be speaking from a position of complete ignorance. I beg of you all to use your common sense. This has nothing to do with the left vs the right. I’m a Democrat who is voting for Crouch.
Prosecutors are responsible for obtaining convictions. Judges have the exclusive responsibility to impose sentences. The State of Maryland developed the Maryland Sentencing Guidelines to assist judges in fashioning an appropriate sentence. These guidelines are available to the public through the Code of Maryland Agency Regulations.
The “soft on crime” criticism is frequently leveled at elected prosecutors running for reelection in a contested campaign.
The case cited today against DiGregory occurred during the pandemic when few were being incarcerated. For health reasons, home detention and ankle monitors were used more often than not in lieu of incarceration. The judge’s sentence in that case fell within the recommended range of the Maryland Sentencing Guidelines.
You would have more credibility if you didn’t hide behind an alias in this tendentious commentary. All, or most of us on this page are not concealing who we are.
What’s the real issue here? It is not at all clear from the back and forth. Is it that the current State’s Attorney is too tough? Or too lenient? Or something else? At the end of the day, judges and juries get to dispense justice. Neither front line law enforcement personnel nor prosecutors should try to place too much weight on the scale.
First, it’s incorrect to say I’ve been away from the State’s Attorney’s Office for 27 years, although technically my time as the elected State’s Attorney did end in early January 2000. I returned to the State’s Attorney’s Office as an assistant state’s attorney in 2017-2018. The last criminal case I tried was in 2018. A professional guideline for prosecutors’ offices that is just as important today as it was during my time in the office, recommends that the top prosecutor be experienced in jury trials, preferably criminal jury trials. Soon after the next term begins, there are two homicide cases on the Circuit Court docket for trial by jury.
Second, I’m not questioning the legitimacy of the FOP Lodge’s endorsement and have no reason to do so. I’ve always figured the FOP followed its rules for such matters. The endorsement was determined by a majority vote of those present at a meeting and it was not unanimous. I am curious about the extent of officer participation in that meeting because there have been inferences that the endorsement represents the opinion of all Kent County officers. The endorsement is a legitimate statement by the FOP as an organization, and of course it’s helpful when one is running for office. It does not, however, represent the opinion of all Kent County law enforcement.
Third, no one suggested that previous support somehow creates a lifetime obligation.
Finally, there are vague references to challenges with the present State’s Attorney’s Office that provide a basis for not re-electing DiGregory. The most specific thing I’ve heard thus far is a claim that DiGregory puts too much emphasis on a grant-funded, interdisciplinary recidivism prevention program that operates out of his office. I think it would be helpful for the public to have more information about the challenges and what remediation is proposed.
At what point have we all stopped listening? Our Sheriff works hard along side of all law enforcement day in and out to keep our community safe and is sharing his opinion. Why aren’t we listening? Why is this about opening our mouths to make judgement of his character instead of hearing his valued opinion in what he faces everyday, not just at election time? Let’s utilize having two ears and two eyes so that we can all listen to each other and see what’s actually going on. Let’s do our own research and learn everyone’s position in all of this. Let’s understand that the moment we have come to a conclusion we have stopped learning and stopped listening. Instead of finding anger and defensiveness and making a judgement of our Sheriff, let’s continue to have a conversation about how to make our community better and safer.
I agree with Jackie as she speaks out for more conversations that make our community better, safer. I said it before in my original post on this subject: I hold Sheriff Hickman in high regard. He has been a good law enforcement officer throughout his career. My point was about courtesy and a conversation that didn’t happen. It was a missed opportunity to have a conversation that might have been productive for law enforcement and the public good, during a bumpy time in which teammates disagree.